


                STAR TREK NEW OR OLD GENERATIONS
                ================================

                   BOB KELL COMPARES THE TWO



       I`ve just watched Star  Trek  Generations  and  although I must
admit I enjoyed the film,it  only  reinforced  my opinion that William
Shatner is Star Trek.The few scenes that he was in are the best in the
film,they are the real Star Trek.The  Next Generation stars are pretty
good in their own show but I  think  that  it was a mistake to combine
the two casts as it really  only  serves  to show up the new cast,they
are no where near as good as the originals.
       When you compare roughly the same characters from the series,it
becomes painfully obvious that the  new  cast  are severely lacking in
most areas.Beverly Crusher is a prime example,a totally wooden actress
taking the ship`s doctors part part played so brialliantly by DeForest
Kelly as McCoy.In the old  show  there  was  no problem believing that
McCoy`s word would be held  in  great  store by the Captain,whereas in
the new series I personally  find  her  character totally flat and why
she has a major part at all is in itself a mystery.
       As science officer,Spock was Kirk`s  right  hand  man and had a
huge  influence  on  the  running   of   the  ship  and  advising  the
Captain.What do we  get  in  the  next  generation?,porky Will Ryker,a
nookie obsessed number one who always seems to give out all the orders
while Picard sits on his arse in the big comfy chair.As the cast reads
down it gets worse.Deanna Troi,the  obligatory telepath,Worf,now he is
a  total  dork,O`Brien,he   is   so   inconspicuous   he`s  not  worth
mentioning,LaForge,compare him to Scotty,enough said.
       The only ones I`d spare  from  criticism are Wesley Crusher,who
is not in it nearly  often  enough,and  Data,an excellent character in
the series but  why  oh  why  did  they  bugger  his  part  up  in the
movie.That bit  about  his  emotion  chip  was  really,really awful,it
totally knackered his whole part in the film.
       Actually when I think  about  it  there  are  some other really
shitty bits in the new series.That  whole Holodeck thing is pushing it
to the limit.When they go  into  the  room  when the holograms are not
activated,it`s a bare room about 40 feet square.When it`s in operation
it turns  into  the  Tardis,they  can  walk  for  miles,drop  into the
sea,drive away in cars,surely a  hologram  would  only create a visual
illusion  not  an  alternate  universe.And,if  they  can  create  such
illusions,why can`t they use it as some form of deceptive weapon along
the lines of a cloaking device.I  bet  Scotty  could convert it with a
spanner and some sellotape.
       Another fault,of both series,is  why,when  they have warp drive
technology,don`t they  consider  fitting  the  away  teams  with video
cameras so that the  ship  can  see  what  the  hell  is going on when
they`re on a planet.Works for Jeremy Beadle.
       Kids on the Enterprise,that`s another  one,why the hell do they
lug  the  whole  family  along   on  the  missions,bloody  daft.Saucer
section,there`s another one,no point.If the ship splits what`s to stop
an enemy second ship blowing the bit with the kids etc to smithereens.
       The Next Generation is,in  itself,a  reasonably good show,but I
don`t think it should be the  sequel  to  Star Trek,it would have been
better to have just had it  as  a new,seperate show,and let the viewer
decide themselves about it`s origins.The  major  problem seems to rest
with the guys who  dream  up  the  story  lines.In the original,almost
every episode revolved around the discovery  of some weird lifeform or
some strage phenomena,and the way that  Kirk  and co dealt with it was
invariably of huge importance to  the  rest  of  the galaxy.In the new
series a lot of the episodes are  more about the actual characters and
events in their individual lives,the setting of the starship is purely
incidental,it  may  as  well   be   Crossroads  sometimes.And  that  Q
character,the absolute pits.
       One last criticism.The lack  of  imagination of the writers.Why
are 95% of the friendly aliens who  are  crew members or at least good
guys,blue skinned.Blue seems to be a stock colour for nice guy aliens.
Why is there always  the  obligatory  telepath.Why  is  there always a
shape shifter alien,surely that`s been  done  to  death.Why is there a
bald woman,the shock value of a  baldy  babe has long gone.There seems
to be a terrible lack of  new  ideas in sci-fi programs and films.Deep
Space Nine has all the usual cliches as does Babylon 5.The stories are
dull and  repetitive,they`ve  been  done  in  several  book  and films
before.Even the likes of  Dr  Who  and  The  Hitchhikers  Guide To The
Galaxy  had  more  original  ideas.Films  like  Dark  Star,2001,Silent
Running and Alien  were  at  least  inventive  in  their  own time.The
current crop of TV sci-fi  is  still  living  on their success and are
not,unfortunately,creating anything new of their own.


Pisses me off.
