                                                                
Oh No, It's An    /\     |\    /| |  /\     /\              
   /  \    | \  / |   |    |         /  \             
                /____\   |  \/  |   |    |  ___   /____\             
               /      \  |      |   |    \    |  /      \          
              /        \ |      | __|__   \___/ /        \          
                                                             
            /|   /|      /\       /\       /\ 
           / /| |  /_/| |     /_/\ \     / /\ \     / /\ \
          / /  | |     | |          > >   / /   \ \   / /   \ \
         /    |     | |         / /   < <     > > < <     > >
        / /| |     | |        / /     \ \   / /   \ \   / /
       / /     | |   __| |__    _/ /___    \ \_/ /     \ \_/ /
      /_/      |_|  [_______]  [_______]    \___/       \___/ 
      _____________________________________________________________
     <_____________________________________________________________>

    _________________________________________________________________
    | A long time ST owner assesses the new AMIGA A1200 and reports |
    |       on its impact on that rare bird, the Atari Falcon       |
    

I  just couldn't wait any longer for Falcon.  I needed to upgrade to  a 
computer  that  could offer colourful high-res  graphics,  true  multi-
tasking,  and have good expansion potential particularly graphics, hard 
disks,  memory  etc.  I had really 'outgrown' my STE.  The best PD  and 
commercial  software just wasn't enough,  while MiNT multi-tasking  was 
impressive but too much of a 'hit and miss' affair as far as making  my 
favourite programs co-operate was concerned.

I had always wanted a Falcon,  but at the beginning of April I realised 
it  would probably be at least 6 months before the Falcon was  released 
properly and have enough software support to make it worth buying.  I'd 
also  needed  to wait to save more cash following the price rise - 599
for  a basic 1 megabyte and 999 for a decent spec machine does seem  a
lot  of  money  - I mean a grand and that's with no specific  software?
Maybe I'd have to wait for a price drop.  This could take it into 1994.

I had recently been using an Ambra 486DX 33mhz PC at work and liked  it 
very  much.  I  have always liked PC's and a 486 PC would  satisfy  the 
critera mentioned above,  but again you're talking about a grand for  a 
good system.

I'd had a nasty experience with an Amiga A500 last year (I borrowed one 
for  two weeks) which put me off Commodore but maybe I should  look  at 
the A1200?  At 399 for a 2 megabyte machine it is considerably cheaper 
than a Falcon or PC.   In addition, a local department store was having 
a  sale  and lopped 40 off the price!  359 for 32bit  power  could  I 
refuse?

No is the short answer.  But what about the Falcon, and Atari? That was 
my  first thought.  Sod them was my second thought.  Not very  loyal  I 
know,  but then what do you expect?  The Falcon's had more false starts 
than the Grand National, the price goes up, then Atari take a step back 
in time with the relaunch of the STFM!

SPECIFICATIONS

Unless  you  read the Amiga mags you probably won't  know  the  A1200's 
specifications, so here it is:

The main CPU is a Motorola 68EC020 running at 14.19Mhz, and 2 megabytes 
of memory as standard.  This is 'chip ram' (that is, memory that can be 
accessed by the graphics and audio custom chips) and cannot go above  2 
megabytes. In addition, a 8 megabytes  of fast ram  (only accessable by
programs)  can be added via the 'trap door' underneath the machine  (no 
need to open it up) and also via the PCMCIA slot on the side.

GRAPHICS AND SOUND

The  A1200 features the new AGA graphics chip set,  which has  a  total 
colour  palette  of  16.8 million colours (REAL  true  colour)  with  a 
maximum  of  262,000  colours  at once,  with  a  very  wide  range  of 
resolutions like 320x256, 640x480,  1280x256 etc,  all of which can  be 
interlaced  and  overscanned.  A multisync monitor is  needed  for  VGA 
resolutions  and to get other 'no flicker' high  resolutions.  You  can 
also  set virtual resolutions up to 16384x16384 and scroll  around  the 
screen.  Audio wise,  the A1200 is the same as the old Amigas's with  8 
bit 4 channel stereo sound.

It  also  has an IDE hard drive controller and  internal  mounting  (as 
Falcon), but lacks a SCSI port, MIDI ports, High Density drive, DSP, 16 
bit audio, lan and the extra power of the 68030.

The Basic A1200 can be bought for 360. Adding an 80mb hard disk and an 
extra  2mb  Ram  takes it to about 684 which compares  well  with  the 
Falcons  999 with a similar spec.  A 68030 based Amiga A4000 in  a  PC 
style  box costs the same as the Falcon and comes with a hard disk  and 
4mb of Ram but the CPU is 25mhz although there is still no DSP.

Graphically,  the  Amiga has a larger palette and a HAM8 mode  to  give 
262,000  colours on screen,  but this has 2 drawbacks.  Not all  pixels 
can be any colour - because the Hold and Modify mode uses somes  tricks 
to  get  the  colours,  some 'fringing' can  occur  with  pixels  being 
incorrectly  coloured.  It  is  also  quite slow  because  of  the  HAM 
calculations that have to be worked out.

In practise, although the Falcon cannot display as many colours,  it's 
true colour mode does not suffer from HAM problems and should also  be 
quicker  at updating, and  results  should be  at least at good as the 
Amiga.  768x480  pixels is also not far off the highest resolution the
Amiga can handle.

There is a lot of talk in the Amiga mags about the Falcons only  having 
16 bit Ram and how the DSP has to wait for data from the CPU which  can 
slow it down etc, etc.  I don't know how much of what they say is  true
(although  Atari say the DSP and CPU can work in tandem), but I can say
the the A1200  is no speed freak!  In fact,  even doing  simple  things 
takes a lot  longer on the A1200  compared  to the STE  because of  the
Workbench environnment and slow floppy disks.

WORKBENCH 3


- is the Amiga's windowing environment like GEM, while AmigaDOS is like 
TOS.  A  comprehensive Unix style command line interpreter is  supplied 
with  Workbench,  and  Arexx is a programming language  also  supplied, 
although  no  documentation is supplied with the machine on  either  of 
these.

The Unfortunate thing about Workbench is that like MS-DOS on the PC (or 
even  Windows) most of the commands,  libraries and other system  files 
are  on  disk  and  when you load  a  program  from  another  disk,  it 
invariably  needs  a file from the workbench boot disk  before  it  can 
continue loading.  This adds up to a lot of disk-swapping and the  880k 
Amiga disk drives are dreadfully slow and make awful screeching  noises 
(which is  normal). Obviously, without a hard disk, using the A1200 can 
quickly drive you up the wall.

PC (or ST)  disks can be read and written to  using the driver supplied
with Workbench and the Amiga treats these disks  as normal Amiga disks,
although the first time I used this it wiped one of my ST disks!

IT'S NO FRIEND OF MINE


I  thought  Commodore  had reached the  pinnacle of user-unfriendliness
with the C64,  but they've surpassed themselves with the  Amiga!  Maybe 
it's just because of the disk-swapping and lack of  documentation,  but 
I'd rather have the operating system fully on ROM any day. In fact, I'd
rather dump Workbench altogether and have GEM or WINDOWS!

Workbench is confusing,  even to someone like myself who has been using 
PC's  and ST's for years.  It does have some good points  though.  It's 
multi-tasking  ability is  very impressive - you can even format a disk
then go and do something else! You can exit  some  programs by dragging
the screen down with the mouse, revealing  the Workbench screen  behind
it.  I  haven't yet worked out how to stop a program that  has  crashed 
though,  something  that happened the other day.  The Amiga  was  still 
working  fine, I could return to the workbench screen but couldn't kill 
the program that had crashed - time to reboot (again)...

Also from within Workbench,  you can set up printer drivers which other 
programs can use,  palette, overscan position and sizing, screen modes, 
keyboard/mouse rate,  country settings - it is much like Windows as far 
as customizing your system goes.

VERDICT


After  using the A1200 for about a month now I can honestly  say,  that 
overall   it  is a load of rubbish.  Yes,  it can  multi-task  and  the 
graphics  are  good,  but it is slow,  very difficult to get  to  grips 
with and needs a hard disk if you are going to use it seriously.  Maybe 
I should have been warned by the low price - you certainly get what you 
pay for with the A1200.

I am not surprised so many Amiga's are used solely for playing games  - 
it's damn difficult to get it to do anything else! 

WHAT YOU SHOULD DO


If you are looking to upgrade from your ST,  my advice is wait for  the 
Falcon (in it's new case) if you can.  It will probably be some  months 
before this happens,  but will be worth it. If a Falcon doesn't appeal, 
try a 486 PC with Windows 3.1 Above all keep your ST,  you'll find  you 
keep coming back to it, and DON'T buy anything from Commodore. Cheap or 
not!

My  earlier  comments about Atari still stand - what  are  they  doing? 
Not even an hint of what they're up to or any kind of timescale for the 
Falcon's release.  Hopefully the opening of a new European distribution 
centre  in Holland signals the start of something good.  Or maybe  not, 
you know Atari.

In the mean-time I've got to look for some fool who will buy this A1200 
junk off of me...


RETAILERS VIEW


The retailers seem to be losing interest in the Falcon.  When I  bought 
my  A1200 from a large department store with a  well  stocked  computer 
department,  I quizzed the salesman on the Falcon.  I was expecting him 
to say he didn't know about it but he did. Their buying department last 
contacted Atari 1 month previously and were told it would be a few more 
months  before they could have any!  This delay coupled with  the  slow 
sales  of ST and software plus the high price,  means it is  'unlikely' 
they will be selling the Falcon.

