3 (of 3) AVATAR Mar.  9, 1987 at 23:18 Eastern (20668 characters)
  
                                 LESSON TWO

                   THE CHURCH SPREADS ACROSS THE EMPIRE:
                 THE CONCEPT OF "RITE" IN THE EARLY CHURCH.

         Fifty  days after the Resurrection of Our Lord the Apostles,   the
Mother of Christ, and a group of other disciples of the Lord (About 120  in
all,   says the Acts of the Apostles)   were gathered together in the Upper
Room in obedience to the command Christ had given before His Ascension that
his  followers were to go to Jerusalem and to wait there for The  Comforter
Whom He would send.

         The Paraclete did,  indeed,  come.   He came in a flash of  flame,
with the sound of roaring wind, and in tongues of fire.  And from that room
(which must have been a large room,  indeed,  to have held 120  people with
any  comfort)    this tiny group set out to conquer a world.   And that  is
precisely  what they did,  conquer a world.   It took a while for  them  to
organize a community in Jerusalem, even though they DID make 3,000 converts
on  that firct momentous day.   Even though converts were made,  it took  a
considerable  amount  of  time  to  instruct them in  the  faith,   and  to
strengthen them in it to such a degree that they (the new converts)   could
be  trusted to hew to it under any and all circumstances.  And  there  must
have  been a good many early defections,  if for no other reason than  from
fear.    It would have taken quite a while for the disciples themselves  to
have gotten over their shock and confusion, and to strengthen each other in
the Faith,  indeed, to begin grappling with it.   Signs of confusion in the
minds of the Apostles runs all through the New Testament, including Peter's
own insights into his personal revelations.

         You  may  well be wondering what all this history has to  do  with
sanctity,  or with liturgy, or with Lent.  You ought not.   It is important
for   your   own   sanctification  (which  makes  it  important   for   the
sanctification of this parish and of this village as a consequence)    dhat
you begin to understand the nature of sanctity and holiness itself - not as
something  achievable  only  by the especially gifted,  but  that  sanctity
itself has little enough intrinsic to do with quiet,  placid manners,  with
gentle piety or even with the heroic patience and inherent loveableness  we
generally  associate with "sainthood."   Sanctity is not at all like  that.
It  (the word "sanctity")  derives from the Latin root "sanctus."    It  is
usually translated as "holy,"  but its REAL meaning is "specially set aside
for  the  exclusive service of [a deity]."   And THEREFORE  "sanctity"   is
"holiness,"   because holy things ARE ESPECIALLY SET  ASIDE,   CONSECRATED,
DEDICATED,  TO THE SERVICE OF DIVINITY.   And,  as we all know (Because St.
Paul  has  so explicitly told us so)   God does NOT choose for His  special
service the strong,  the powerful, the brilliant,  those who are inherently
good;   He  chooses to make His might known through using the weak  as  His
instruments.   Men are called to the priesthood NOT because they are better
men, but because they are WEAKER men, and in their sanctification the might
and goodness of God becomes evident.   You,  each of you,  are called to be
Christians,   not because you are somehow more virtuous than  others,   but
because you are NOT.   And again,  God's might and goodness become manifest
in what His grace permits you to achieve.

         Following  the  development  of the Church and its  early  members
allows us to understand how very real and very weak and insignificant human
beings  began to change the very nature of the world around them by  little
more than their devotion to and loving service of Jesus Christ.   With  the
quality of these first Christians the Church itself would stand or fall.

         The  first real break with the Jewish community in Jerusalem  came
with the vision Peter had of Christ on the rooftop at Joppa,  where  Christ
showed  Peter  in a shockingly graphic fashion that mankind had,   at  long
last,  been cleansed,  and purified, and that he,  Peter,  was no longer to
call  unclean  what Jesus Christ had cleansed.   Peter had been told  in  a
vision  to  visit  Joppa  and go to the house of a  Roman  centurion  named
Cornelius,  and to convert him to the cause of Christ without the formality
of  circumcision.    It  would  be  long  before  Peter  grasped  the  full
significance  of this visit and this vision,  and it would require Paul  to
remind  him of it - but it had been made clear that mankind wac again  one.
This vision, this message, was no small thing, because it ran quite counter
to  the entire history of the Jews,  a  history which had marked them as  a
people  set  apart,  and that apartness had been reinforced for a  thousand
years by dietary regulations,  sabbath rules,  rules of conduct both social
and private,  worship ritual and a host of other things that,  quite  apart
from  Jewish monotheism,  set them even further apart from the rest of  men
than did their theology alone.  A direct precedent had been established, at
the command of Christ Himself, that Gentiles were to be allowed to join the
Church  without first observing the Mosaic Law - and the message  had  been
given even before the famous controversy between Paul and Peter.

         The second great break came with St.  Stephen's conversion of  the
eunuch, secretary to Queen Candace of Ethiopia.  The eunuch was baptized in
a running stream near the roadside,  again without benefit of circumcision,
and  without the obligation of fulfilling or observing the other rituals of
the Mosaic Law.

         Following these two incidents, Peter himself went up to Asia Minor
to  check  on the work of Paul in Greece and the area now known as  Turkey,
and  centered  his  activities  in and around  the  provincial  capital  of
Antioch,  where Christians were first called by that name.   He established
himself  there  as  head of the local community - and he  continued  to  be
acknowledged  by  the  rest of the Apostles as leader  of  dhe  College  of
Apostles,  though doubtlessly none of them ever thought of it as such.   It
was  here at Antioch that the famous dispute between Peter and aul finally
came to a head.

         Paul was,  however,  doing such a tremendous job in the conversion
of  the Eastern Empire,  it must have seemed advisable to Peter not to  re-
invent  the  wheel,  and to see what could be done elsewhere.    The  other
Apostles  proceeded  along much the same lines,  and  scattered  themselves
throughout the known world.   Peter moved westward to Rome,  the center  of
the  Empire,   leaving  another in charge in his place.    There  he  again
established himself as head,  not only of the group of Apostles,  but again
of  the  local  community.   There he died,  first bishop  of  Rome.    The
archaeological excavations beneath St. Peter's Basilica under Pope Pius XII
seem  to have satisfied beyond reasonable doubt the ancient tradition  that
the  body  of  Peter  lies buried directly beneath the main  altar  of  the
basilica;   that  the  ancient tradition seems to  have  been  surprisingly
accurate  - far more accurate than scholars of a few decades ago would have
believed.

         The  other  Apostles varied their activities at least  as  widely.
St.  Paul surely had no monopoly on missionary activity,  though he left by
far the greater number of Epistles behind him.  Neither did St. Peter.  St.
Mark, traditionally the companion of St. Peter, is reported by tradition to
have  gone to Alexandria,  Egypt,  following Peter's death,  and become its
first  bishop.  St.  Andrew is supposed to have travelled  through  Russia,
Scandinavia,  Scotland and the British Isles, through the Iberian Peninsula
and  back around through Italy and Greece to die on his X-shaped  cross  in
what  is now modern Turkey.   St.  Thomas,  of course,  is reputed to  have
converted  thousands  to Christianity in India,  where there  still  remain
Christians  of Malabarese and Syro-Malankarese rite,  still called to  this
very day "St. Thomas' Christians."

         It  seems that the common hallmark of Apostolic activity was  that
their  activities seem not to have been restricted to any single geographic
area.    Each Apostle seems free to have roamed where the Spirit moved him;
that they made their converts when and where they could,  then left another
in charge to reap the harvest as they passed on their way to other pastures
and  other flocks.   In this way they could cover the most ground and reach
the  most people,  returning only occasionally (or sending emissaries to do
the  job for them)   to check up on the conditions of the infant  churches,
and to correct any corruptions which may have crept in.   The typical  mode
of operation seems to be similar to that employed by St.  Paul in his three
missionary journeys in his search for souls.

         As  the  Apostles  moved  around  establishing  churches,    local
communities,   they  appear to have appointed those who were to  offer  the
Sacrifice of Christ to take their places on their departures, and these men
naturally enough modelled their observances of the worship on the manner in
which the individual Apostle offered his sacrifice.  In the course of time,
various additions and accretions crept in,  and were incorporated into what
became an increasingly stylized manner of offering the Sacrifice, as befits
the  dignity  of  the offering.   But since there were  so  many  different
Apostles,   and  they  were preaching to so very many  different  types  of
people,  gith different mentalities, different customs,  different outlooks
on life,  different culture,  different law,  different civilization,  they
took  whatever  of a given culture could be turned to the glorification  of
God.    So,   use of incense became common among Greeks and Romans,   while
dancing, drums and flute music became common among Ethiopians.

         Around the principal cities in any given area,  the Liturgy (as it
came  to be called,  from the Greek "leiturgeia,"  "serving")   came to  be
practiced  in a more or less uniform manner within the boundaries of  given
geographical and economic areas.  The more influential the city, the larger
the area of its sway.

         Still,   the common language of the day was not,  as so many  have
supposed,  Latin,  but Greek, a kind of 'lingua franca' of the day.   Latin
was a very formal language, customarily used at this point,  only on formal
occasions and for formal purposes,  even by Roman citizens themselves.  And
since the common language of the Empire was Greek,  and the language of the
Liturgy  itself  remained Greek,  there tended to be no  great  divergences
between and among the various groups.

         The  picture  changed quickly and drastically,   however,  in  the
Fourth Century,  and even more so in the Fifth.   Shortly after his victory
at  the Milvian Bridge in 312,  Constantine moved the capital of the Empire
to  a  little  fishing village on the Sea of Marmara - Byzantium,   it  was
called then.  He called it "New Rome,"  but it wasn't long before it became
"Constantinople,"  "The City of Constantine"  in Greek.   Now "Istanbul"  -
Turkish for "The City."   By 325  A.D. the capital had been moved,  all the
nobles  of  Rome  had  been  coerced  into  rebuilding  their  palaces  and
residences  in New Rome,  and the seat of government was now far closer  to
the  geographic  center than ever.   When Constantine the Great  moved  the
capital,   Rome  quickly  became little more than a  provincial  backwater.
Latin,  heretofore the language of the educated classes,   now  became  the
common  tongue  once  again as  the  Graecophones  (Greek-speakers)   moved
eastward.   As Rome lost her supply of Greek slaves (who taught, along with
everything else, Greek language to their students,  preparatory to teaching
them  Greek philosophy,  mathematics and art)  she reverted to her original
language,   Rome.    And the language barrier between Eastern  and  Western
portions  of the Empire began to form with a surprising swiftness.   By the
end  of the fourth century and the beginning of the fifth,  the time of St.
Jerome and of St. Augustine the Great, Bishop of Hippo, the western regions
of  the Empire were thoroughly Latinized once again.   So much so that  St.
Jerome had found it practical to translate the Hebrew Scriptures into Latin
for the benefit of those who no longer spoke Greek.

         By 420,  Rome had fallen to the barbarian hordes and been  sacked.
Soon the barbarian Ostrogoths had their own King in Rome,  and  Theodoric's
dynasty was established,  and within a century thereafter, St.  Benedict of
Nursia had established his communal life in Monte Cassino.  The Benedictine
Order had been born.

         Once  the linguistic barriers were raised,  problems multiplied in
many areas.   Not least among them the area of liturgical practice.   Where
there was little or no linguistic understanding there was soon no fraternal
understanding,  or compassion,  for that matter.   Differences were  highly
magnified  and  tended  to increase with greater and  greater  speed  until
things developed to a point where what we now think of as "rites"  (I.E., a
collection  of  ceremonies,  laws,   customs and attitudes  peculiar  to  a
particular group of people),  were now real entities.  Previous differences
had been viewed more as personal or local eccentricities,  so to speak, and
little  consideration had ever been given to the idea that permission  from
elsewhere to do things somewhat differently would be needed.  Indeed,  in a
world  where  everyone did,  in fact,  understand what others did and  why,
there would be no NEED to intervene.   Intervention by Rome was not unheard
of,   but  it was far from common.   And "intervention"  had  never  become
confused with "interference," as it seems to be so often nowadays.

         420 was a critical year in the history of the Church.   Until that
time,   even  though  the  Empire was still  locked  in  some  considerable
confusion  as  a reselt of the shift of capitol cities,  it still liked  to
THINK of itself as one empire.   Once Rome was sacked and had fallen to the
barbarians,  leaving Constantinople (as it thought)   the sole defender  of
Orthodoxy  within  the Empire,   (These barbarians were heretics,  commonly
known  as  Arian.    The term has nothing to do with  our  modern-day  term
"Aryan,"   which is another word entirely),   since only the area under the
control of Constantinople was, properly speaking, either "orthodox"  in its
doctrine  or within the ambit of empire.   Peter had definitely  moved  the
sphere of his activities to Rome precisely BECAUSE it WAS the center of the
Empire,   administratively,   economically  and otherwise.    It  was  most
assuredly  the  center of Imperial communications.   Now  that  center  had
fallen to heretics and pagans.   Was it not natural,  considering the state
of political theory of the time,  that there would be some confusion as  to
the real source of authority within the Church?   Where there is confusion,
there is bound to be error.  Not all error is ill-intentioned.   Some of it
is honest.  Honest mistakes, however, remain mistakes, and the consequences
of  honest  mistakes  are every bit as devastating to those  who  feel  its
impact as a deliberate act.    Over the next couple of centuries,  although
the question of political supremacy was never really explicitly settled, it
was at least ignored in the apparent interests of harmony, and some sort of
working arrangement was beached when it was decreed in Council that the See
of Constantinople, never one of the Apostolic Sees, but by this time raised
to the Patriarchate because of its proximity to the Imperial Throne,  would
henceforward  be  second in pre-eminence to the See of Rome.    I  find  it
rather  astonishing  that there would be any real  question  of  historical
evidence  for  the early pre-eminence for the See of Rome (as so many  non-
Catholic  groups  do)  since a pre-requisite for such an arrangement  would
necessarily be the quite explicit understanding and acceptance OF the  pre-
eminence  of Rome.   At this point in the development of the Church,  these
people  were  no farther from the death of St.  John (or not much more  so)
than we are from our own Declaration of Independence.

         For  some centuries,  up until the eighth century and the rise  of
the Carolingian Empire (Charlemagne),  relations were reasonably good, with
occasional friction erupting and finding expression in doctrinal or  ritual
disagreements.  Nothing outrageouc - yet.  But from the eighth to the tenth
centuries  there  was  an unfortunate degeneration in  the  moral  life  of
Western  clergy,   while that of the East remained relatively  high.    The
untoward  influence  of  the  rulers of the new empire  which  arose  after
Charlemagne's  death  in the selections of occupants of  the  papal  throne
quite  disgusted Eastern Christianity.   One suspects largely because  they
viewed  the  Western Emperor as a competitor to their own  splendid  court.
The  very  center of western intellectual activity was  in  Constantinople,
where  were found the best schools of the time,  the highest culture,   the
finest art,  the best clerical training.   Western figures suffered greatly
by comparison, often ignorant in the extreme,  and the personal manners and
mannerisms  of  westerners  were offensive to  the  Imperial  court.    For
example, the Patriarch Photius, though he split with Rome several times and
re-united  several times,  was one of the most intelligent men of his time,
fluent   in  several  languages  (including  Latin,   unlike  his   western
counterparts,  who all too often could read no Greek, whose Latin was often
poorer  than  his),   broadminded,  cultured,  and a man  of  unimpeachable
personal  morals.   His opposite number in Rome,  the Pope of his day  was,
unfortunately,  a man of far less relative personal capability.  It is good
to  remember  that God's grace requires no brilliant men  through  whom  to
work,   only  men willing to serve Him faithfully.  As  did  Peter.    This
unfavorable comparison raised its ugly head all too often and sowed further
seeds  of  dissension.    Here were what Greeks considered  to  be  uncouth
barbarians  presuming to dictate the Truths of the Faith to those who  were
far better versed in intellectual training and capability.  Why, for pity's
sakes, the Pope couldn't even read GREEK!  And, appropriately shocked, they
reacted quite predictably.

         The situation continued to grow worse until the unfobtunate events
of  the eleventh and twelfth centuries - the decisive split of 1056  making
more  or  less permanent the split between West and East.   Those  who  had
previously been "Orthodox"  now became "Catholic"  while those who had been
"Eastern"   now became "Orthodox."   All of which did little to reduce  the
levels of confusion,  anger, bitterness and vitriol.   And with that split,
the  concept  of  rite  became solidified.    The West,  looking  upon  the
'tradition',  as they called it,  of heresy and schism in the East,   could
find  no trust in their hearts for their Eastern brethren,  even though  it
took  several centuries more to finalize the break permanently with seferal
groups.    The  Russian  group,  for example,  broke finally  only  in  the
fifteenth century, after the Council of Florence.  Until that time they had
maintained  sporadic  relations with both Rome and New Rome.   Saintly  and
brilliant men such as Saint Isidore, Archbishop of Kiev, did wonderful work
in  maintaining relatively harmonious relationships between the two groups,
in addition to his lucid thinking at the Council itself.

         But the seeds of mistrust were sown, and Western tendencies to use
law,   force and authority upon those whom they mistrusted began to  assume
the  uppermost positions of awareness in Western minds,  and the West began
to grant 'permissions' for what had theretofore been considered the natural
prerogative  of individual groups.   The situation worsened steadily,   and
finally erupted in what is known as 'The Reformation.'   And I am convinced
to  this  day that,  had the schism between East and West  never  occurred,
there would have been no Reformation, eidher.

         Next:   the basic differences between Eastern and  Western  Rites;
attitudes, customs, mentality, laws, approaches, spirituality.
