4 (of 4) AVATAR Mar. 16, 1987 at 18:15 Eastern (12410 characters)
  
                       LESSON THREE - EAST MEETS WEST

         Before the Capitol of the Empire was moved from West to East, from
Rome  to  New Rome - Constantinople - education in the Empire was  more  or
less  uniform,  what there was of it.    Most of the leisured  classes  had
received  pretty  much  the same education,  wherever you went  within  the
Empire, whether you lived in Rome, in Tarshish on the Iberian Peninsula, or
in Tarsus in Asia Minor, a very well-to-do city which had among its schools
some of the very best available anywhere in the world of that day.  That is
to say, the leisured classes received educations which were very cimilar to
each  other in that,  like the schools of the Middle Ages and  Renaissance,
very  mech  depended upon and derived from Greek thought and  system,   and
(pardon the mixed metaphors)  a Greek "Weltanschauung." (German for "way of
seeing the world.")  Viewpoints tended to be very much the same  throughout
the Roman world, and so attitudes were very probably quite similar as well.

         It   follows,    then,   that  there  would  be  little   if   any
differentiation  of  any  real substance in religious  theology,   even  as
undeveloped as it was.   Early Christians were, for the moct part, those of
the lower classes, and (at least in the very early decades of the Christian
era)    largely of the slave class,  which means that they were mainly non-
Roman, non-Italian and even non-Western.

         However, once that fundamental change in the structure of Imperial
life had been made,  the language barrier which developed prevented a  free
and  easy  interchange  of thought in general.   The  fact  that  religious
thought  turned  out  to have a disproportionate influence  on  daili  life
simply  added to the significance of the catastrophic consequences of  that
breakdown.    Theological  communication was restricted to those  who  were
fluent in two or more languages (and those proved few enough, with the bulk
of  them  concentrated  in the East),  and theology tended  to  become  the
exclusive  property  of the few;  that easy fact gave rise tot  he  Gnostic
heresies,   which held thad there was a special revelation for the few  who
were  initiated  (and  "smart enough"  to be able  to  "understand"   these
difficult  concepts,  or special enough to be especially "chosen,"  "elect"
for  this  special  revelation)   into the "secrets"  of  Greek  and  Roman
philosophy, and the theologies of their exotic religious practices.

         In the East, the basic theological discussions and arguments arose
over questions of Trinitarian and/or Christological nature;  i.e., over the
nature of the Trinity, and over precise questions of the exact relationship
of Christ's human nature and his divine nature.   These questions continued
to  plague  the  East for many centuries after the disputes were,   in  all
actuality,  settled,  though there has been a remarkable resurgence in  the
nineteenth  and twentieth centuries of both Nestorianism and Arianism,   in
different guises and under different names.

         The  West  found itself more concerned with the problem  of  human
free will and itc relationship to God's omniscience, and to predestination,
and  the  further  question of exactly how  Christ's  redemptive  sacrifice
brings grace to man.   The questions concerning the nature of grace  itself
are derivative in nature.

         The  West  concerned itself far more with the problems  associated
with Sin,  Free Will and Predestination,  and with the mechanisms by  which
Christ's redemptive sacrifice brought grace to mankind.

         This  is,  in itself,  a  rather fundamental division.   The  very
attitudes  and presumptions by which we take our first steps to approaching
God  are  different.   Is it surprising,  then,   that the results  of  our
toddling steps are so very different?   In the East,  the emphasis was (and
still is, for that matter) on a God who became man, Who arose from the dead
and ascended into heaven,  and is currently seated there at the right  hand
of  His Father,  waiting to come again at the Parousia,  the Second Coming.
In  the West,  the emphasis is of a God who became man and who died for the
sins of mankind.

         For  these  reasons  you  will notice  when  entering  most  Roman
churches, as opposed to Byzantine churches or churches of other rites,  the
thing  of  greatest  pre-eminence (At least until the time  of  the  Second
Vatican  Council's  reforms took place)  was the Crucifix,  while  in  most
Oriental  churches,  especially in those which are closer to  the  Oriental
tradition and not heavily latinized,  the most prominent thing is the altar
itself.    Instead of a dominating crucifix there is usually painted (or in
mosaic, somedimes.  A lovely custom.)  an icon often named The Pantocrator,
(Greek  for  "The Creator of Everything")  i.e.,  an  all-powerful  Christ,
Risen, Ascended into Heaven, and now seated on His throne in all His glory.
The same emphasis is true of the entire spiritual traditions of which these
items are indicative.   The West maintains a heavy emphasis on the  agonies
of  the Passion.   The East on the glory of Recurrection,  though this  has
changed considerably since the reforms of the Council.

         The spiritual tradition of the East is a strongly hesychiast  one,
by  which I mean there is an astonishingly heavy emphasis on the  necessity
of silence,  of peace, and of personal union with Christ; sometimes this is
emphasized  to  the  detriment of what is often necessary  activity.    For
Eastern  spirituality,  if you will pardon me borrowing a Latin  expression
from  the  Thomistic scholars,  the key concept is  that  "agitur  sequitur
esse,"  -  "doing follows being."  Translated into simple tebms,  it simply
means that we ought not worry too greatly about what to do, but rather more
about what to BE, since the things one does is consequent, or follows upon,
what one has become.   Carpenters build,  mechanics fix,  birds fly,   fish
swim.    Agitur sequitur esse.   "BE"  first,  and the doing will follow as
naturally  as  it comes to fish to swim or birds to fly.     "BE"   another
Christ,   and  you'll not need to struggle with confusion over what to  do,
say,   think,   avoid.    Those will be so completely natural to  you  that
confusion has no origin from which to arise.

         Not so,  the West.   For the West there has always been the  itch,
the urge,  to DO something, to build more churches, bigger churches, richer
churches,  in more places and in more lands,   to acquire for the Church  a
larger  and larger percentage of the population,   to be "doing"  something
constantly, frequently ad the expense of that necessary silence.

         I  do  NOT  mean to imply that Western  traditions  are  therefore
inferior.    I  DO mean to say that there is a place for our traditions  in
this  world,   for the things we Easterners have learned over thousands  of
years of accumulated experience, and that, if we live our lives as we ought
in the service of Christ with the dedication which we ought,  and according
to our spiritual heritage and legacy,  the world can only benefit by having
the accumulated experience of both traditions at its disposal.

         Who  is  there  to say that one tradition is more  necessary  than
another?   Or better?  Surely not I.   The best that I can say is that each
is necessary to counterbalance the ill effects inherent in the other.   Our
tradition of hesychiast (quietist,   complacent,  reflective)  spirituality
brings  with  it  the dangers of solipsism,  of drawing  into  oneself  and
ignoring  the public mission of the Church.   The activist tradition of the
West  has  among  its  inherent dangers,  that of so  involving  itself  in
activist projectc,  the "doing" of things, political or otherwise,  that it
forgets  the need for FIRST acquiring PERSONAL union with Christ.   It  has
with it the danger of becoming a "functionary"  Catholic; i.e.,  that great
danger  so  fraught with disaster and so common in every parish that it  is
enough  to  be  a  good  Catholic to do  what  you're  told,   observe  the
commandments  and  do  as little damage as possible.    Probably  the  most
widespread heresy current in the Church today.

         It is my personal opinion, based on a long and careful scrutiny of
the society in which I live,  that there has been a sufficient emphasis  on
activism  for  a  while,  and that there ought to be  a  greater  and  more
deliberate  emphasis placed on the Oriental approach.   I  found some heavy
interest focused in that direction in the early days following the Council,
but much of that seems to have waned these past few years.

         I  have little to say concerning those who uphold their traditions
at the cost of denigrating those of others,  that is,  except to say "don't
do  it."    We  of  other rites have no need to  disrespect  or  abuse  the
traditions and customs,  the attitudes and mindsets of rites other than our
own.    We  need neither approve nor follow them - but it would  surely  be
contrary to the spirit of Christ's charity to mock them.

         Of all people,  we who have already borne so much ridicele at  the
hands of others who ought to have known better, should now be the very last
to do dhe same.  We should remember,  we Byzantine Catholics in particular,
that  the Church,  even now,  is subject to the direct inspiration of Jesus
Christ  in His Holy Spirit,  and that those things which properly belong to
ANY tradition within the Church are as truly inspired as are our own.

         But  that  necessarily  implies that our  traditions,   too,   are
inspired by God, directly and personally.  And that they are subject to the
guidance of the Holy Spirit working in and through His Church.   We have no
need  to  apologize for our traditions,  or to defend them.   That  we  can
safely leave to Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit.  Whatever defense we need
to  offer  for  our spiritual heritage is amply supplied  by  our  faithful
living of them.

         The only thing we (and the Church as a whole) have need of is that
our  faith be made manifest in the lives of our people to a world  starving
for  the loving touch of the Hand of God - and the only hands it  will  see
are those we use in the service of our Creator.   If the people so  beloved
by  Christ  cannot  obtain the spiritual substance they  require  from  the
storehouses and treasures of one tradition,  they ought to be free to  turn
to  one  which DOES provide a source of that nourishment;   in  particular,
those  who are locked by their own ignorance and lack of  familiarity  with
the  love  of Christ's Church outside the visible bounds of the Kingdom  of
Heaven.

Next Week:  The Nature of the Liturgy in the Catholic Church;  similarities
between the Liturgy in the Byzantine Rite and the Roman Rite,  and a few of
the differences.

         A  short  sketch  of the Liturgy as  the  re-presentation  through
symbol  of  the  entire life of Christ,  and of  the  pre-eminence  of  the
Consecration as the actual unbloody event of Calvary itself,  taken out  of
the bounds of space and time,  and making us present at the moment when the
Kingdom of Heaven was re-opened to mankind.   You ought to be very sure you
understand  that when we speak of "Liturgy"  we are NOT speaking of  a  re-
creation,  a  re-run, a representation which is only symbolic,  but that we
are speaking of the very sacrifice of Calvary itself,  which is now seen in
an unbloody fashion;  therefore,  each and every Divine Liturgy is the very
SAME  liturgy as that celebrated two thousand years ago in  Jerusalem,   in
Antioch  and  Thessalonika;   a   thousand  years  ago  in  Alexandria  and
Constantinople, two days ago in New York City,  five hundred years from now
in Paris.   It is the very SAME sacrifice which,  once offered on the Mount
of Calvary may in the very near future be offered on planets other than the
Earth.    So  also  it  is the same Liturgy as that  which  is  celebrated,
whatever the ritual surroundings,  at different times throughout the entire
world,   and so brings with it the absolute necessity of uniting  ourselves
and  our  intentions with all the liturgies being offered anywhere  in  the
world, of any time and place.
